
Originally Posted by
davewerden
This is actually a bit confusing. Here is the scoop. Bill and Valerie collaborated on the original design, which was a morph of her own French horn strap. Bill bought a batch of them from Valerie to resell. We'll call those strap 1. (That is the first one I owned.)
At some later point Bill apparently had a different maker (we'll call them the Strap2 Company) copy the design. They came pretty close, but the hand strap was shorter, and for me was barely long enough, and the fabric was quite different. I found it not as comfortable, but still usable. We'll call those strap 2. (I have one of those as well, but I went back to strap 1 for comfort.)
Because Bill is out of the market for a while and people still wanted these, I sought out Valerie. The rest you know from the posts here. We'll call the ones she makes now strap 3.
My own strap 1 has been on my horn every time I played, except for the brief time I was using strap 2. It has held up just fine, and I see nothing wrong with the design. (But that's not to say a clever person like Valerie would not still find ways to improve it!)
I think strap 2 is also usable, but not quite as good overall. I can't say if it would last better, or less well, because I have not used it enough.
My own 2 versions of strap 3 arrived today. I'll attach photos of all 3 of my Valerie straps below. The design options are really fun, although they don't contribute to comfort or longevity of course. But the black fleece lining is wonderful! It is much softer on the skin, but not so thick that it is likely to feel hot in the summer. Perfect choice, I think.
My new straps are longer than before, and I think are longer than anyone is likely to need. What do you other owners think? Should I suggest they be a bit shorter?
Below are my photos. The light is not great today and the photos are not as pretty as the straps themselves, but you'll get the idea.