Lincolnshire Posy - Grainger

[RickF]

Our band is planing on playing this great piece at our first concert this season. I've played with Symphonic Band of the Palm Beaches now for nearly 25 years and have to admit I've never played this great piece with this band. Since two of the euphers read only treble clef (self included) I've been busy transposing some parts on Finale. What I noticed is that the band has the original work from 1937 — not Frederick Fennell's version. I've read reports that there are lots of errors in the first printing.

My question is there an errata sheet somewhere that lists the errors of first publication? Thanks.

[davewerden]

I suspect the errata might be within the Brass Compendium that The Instrumentalist magazine published. Not sure if it is still available.

But here is a start on tracking down the issues:

https://www.windrep.org/Lincolnshire_Posy#Errata

[RickF]

Thanks Dave. I found that one but it only says over 500 errors in the original work. Yikes! I suspect there will be lots of 'pencil corrections' on members parts already.

[bbocaner]

All that work to track down and fix errors, and transpose parts, why not just buy the Fennell edition?

[davewerden]

FWIW, it may not be in the Compendium I mentioned. There is no article by Fennell. There is no title starting with "Lincoln..." (although it could be under "A Guide to..." or "Errors in ..." or "Errata for..." etc.). The book is 900 pages, so it might be hiding there. But Barry had the best advice!

[RickF]

Yep, I agree, we should purchase the Fennell version but I don't control the purse strings.

[John Morgan]

Not that I am independently wealthy, which I am not, but to play that piece I would happily purchase the Fennell version and let that be my donation to the band for the year. I have often had to purchase (will probably not had to, but just felt it was appropriate to) the band accompaniments to some of the solos I play. The price to pay to get to play a cool piece of music.

Then, you can also be whatever level of donor to the band that $200 is. And if you have another euphonium player who wants to play a great piece, have him/her go halves with you.

[ann reid]

I’ve downloaded both the euphonium and baritone parts from an online source. I played the whole set one summer about 1/2 a century ago, under the direction of Keith Brion.

My only experience EVER playing in a Keith Brion ensemble OR playing LP.

So I’m working on all the sections, EVERY DAY, during my daily practice.

No sign around here of anyone doing it any time soon, but if I hear of anyone doing it, who also needs a hardworking
geriatric beginner with money enough to buy them a score, I’ll be at the head of the line.

[RickF]

We had a concert last night and it went pretty well. I've always liked 'The Brisk Young Sailor' as I sometimes play it during warmups (if I can't slur the first five notes, I'm not warmed up yet).
I did not play this on baritone but my M5050 so it's darker. Below is a link to an excerpt of that great piece by Percy Grainger if interested.

Lincolnshire Posy - Mov. 4 excerpt:

[davewerden]

Nice job, Rick! Your 5050 is about as far from a baritone as a euphonium can be, but it still works fine.

If I could offer one suggestion... (This is a good general purpose suggestion, but it might be a bit more applicable to a big horn.) I would work to be more clear on the 16th-note passing notes - they are a little lost in the hall. It is often a matter of focusing more on the note and making sure you are still supplying good air support even on the itty-bitty notes.

It's actually my first tip for the Holst 2nd Suite in this video (right around 1:14):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YK3zXDhl83w