2nd Valve Spring(s)

[Rob0Earhart]

I was cleaning the valves on my Bach 1110 euphonium today and saw that my 2nd valve held 2 springs. Before this I had noticed that the action on the 2nd valve wasn't the same as the other 3. Do you have any idea why there would be 2 springs there? I took one of them out and it feels much better.

[carbogast]

2nd Valve Spring(s)

I expect it was just a mistake. - Carroll

[Rob0Earhart]

2nd Valve Spring(s)

I was hoping that's what it was! I asked my brother-in-law (who plays trumpet) and he looked at me like I was stupid.

[davewerden]

2nd Valve Spring(s)

When multiple springs are stored in the same box or package, sometimes a couple may nest together. For a human putting them in a horn, it is not unthinkable that a nested pair could be picked up and inserted. I am not sure how robotic assembly works in this case (or even if it was used for your horn), but I suppose mechanical fingers could pick up a nested pair as well. I suspect one of the above happened with your horn, and that's my theory until a better one comes along!

[prototypedenNIS]

2nd Valve Spring(s)

1 should be enough.
2 may get in each others compression and cause problems.